Fake 1 Star Google Reviews: How to Deal With It?[Answered]

You’re winding down your day, just scrolling through your notifications, when something catches your eye.

It’s a 1-star review on Google. But this isn’t just any bad review—something feels off. No profile photo. No comment. Nothing to explain why it’s there.

You’re pretty sure it’s fake.

But what do you do with a fake 1-star review that could hurt your reputation and push away potential customers? Let’s walk through it step by step.

What Are Fake 1 Star Google Reviews?

As stated in its name, fake 1 star Google reviews are often not credible, misleading, and simply... fake. They are posted as a 1 star to make it look like your business or product isn’t any good.

Now, why does this happen, you may ask? It’s often because...

• Competitors are trying to undercut you. They leave a fake 1 star review to drag down your ratings. A very unfair way to win over your customers.
• Scammers and their extortion. Scams happen everywhere, and fake 1 star reviews are no exception. They do this because they want to blackmail you into sending money to remove them. It’s unethical... but it happens.
• People just don’t seem to like you. This is hypothetical, but maybe a former employee, someone holding a grudge, or a person with a personal issue is using a fake review to get revenge.

All in all, fake 1 star Google reviews are never good. They’re created on purpose and are meant to make sure you get a bad reputation... not just with your existing customers, but with potential ones as well.

How Fake 1 Star Google Reviews Can Hurt Your Business

Now, you might not think that a fake 1 star review can damage a business that much... but these examples from real-life businesses would beg to differ.

Below are case studies that have been greatly impacted because of just fake 1 star reviews.

US Restaurants Extorted

In 2022, restaurants like Parachute in Chicago were flooded with fake 1 star Google reviews, then blackmailed for $75 gift cards. Google took weeks to respond, while bookings fell. Owners had to rally customers to leave real 5-star reviews to push down the fakes.

UK Restaurant Group Blackmailed

Open Restaurant Group in the UK was threatened: pay £2,000 or get 1,000 fake 1 stars. When they refused, 1,000 bad reviews appeared across 6 locations. TripAdvisor removed them fast, but Google was much slower, causing major stress and lost business.

Huge Financial Impact

Fake reviews cost US businesses $152 billion each year in lost sales and reputation damage. Industries like legal, healthcare, and restaurants are hit hardest, with fewer leads and declining trust from potential customers.

Can I Do Something About Fake 1 Star Google Reviews?

Definitely.

Google gives you tools to report and remove fake 1 star reviews, though the process can take time.

You can flag suspicious reviews in your Google Business Profile, submit evidence that they’re fake, and request an official removal.

While not every review gets taken down, consistent reporting and clear documentation often lead to success.

How to Spot and Respond to Fake 1 Star Google Reviews

Fake reviews aren’t always easy to spot, and that’s okay. Below are tips to help you identify fake 1 star reviews, along with simple steps on how you can tackle them.

Tip 1: Watch for Generic or Vague Language

Fake 1 star reviews often use broad or templated wording—think “amazing” or “worst ever”—without specifics.

They may have odd grammar or repetitive phrasing.

How to Respond:

• Ask for details: “Can you tell us when you visited and what went wrong?”
• Highlight your records: “We don’t have a record of this — can you email us so we can help?”
• Flag via your Business Profile: Report the suspicious review to Google for evaluation.

If you’re dealing with one that has no explanation, you can also check our guide on how to respond to a 1 star review without comments for ideas.

Tip 2: Check the Reviewer’s Profile & Review History

Fake reviewers often have no avatar, a generic name, or a strange reviewing pattern—like rating a dozen different businesses in a single day.

How to Respond:

• Investigate their reviews: Click their profile and look for rapid-fire or off-topic reviews.
• If they look suspicious, reply professionally, e.g.:
• “We couldn’t find your name in our system. Please reach out so we can sort this out.”
• Flag the review to Google, providing reasons why the profile looks fake.

Tip 3: Spot Unusual Review Timing or Patterns

A sudden flurry of 1-star reviews—especially in bulk—often signals a coordinated fake review attack.

How to Respond:

• Stay calm and timely in your public reply:
  • Apologize, even if the review seems fake: “Sorry you had this experience...”
  • Direct them offline: “We don’t see this in our records; please contact us here...”
• Flag the clustered reviews together with evidence of timing patterns.

Additional Tips to Strengthen Your Defense

• Encourage genuine reviews: Prompt happy customers to share detailed experiences and photos—volume helps drown out fakes. You can also see our tips on how to encourage customers to write reviews if you’d like step-by-step ideas.
• Track internal records: Keep customer purchase logs so you can quickly check reviewer claims .
• Create a response process: Set templates and assign responsibility so you can act fast if fake reviews appear.

By spotting the red flags, responding calmly, and reporting swiftly—you protect your star rating and demonstrate professionalism to future customers.

Conclusion

We know dealing with fake 1 star Google reviews can feel overwhelming, but you’ve already taken a big step by learning how to spot them and respond with confidence.

If you’d like more guidance, we’ve put together a detailed guide on fake 1 star Google reviews that dives even deeper into what to watch out for.

You can also check out our tips on how to respond to a 1 star review without comments, which many business owners have found helpful.

And if you’re interested in taking your reputation to the next level, feel free to explore how we help businesses with reviews, referrals, customer insights, and repeat business.

You can always find more resources and practical advice on our blog or learn about everything we offer on our website.

Whatever you decide to do next, know that we’re here to help you build trust and stand out—one honest review at a time.

‍